The Wolverine & Rogue Fanfiction Archive
Barely Legal Since 2000
I almost didn't read this. In fact I've read so of your other stories before and intentuly skipped this one. But after having read it, I'm ashamed that I refused to read this before cause I thought it'd be too depressing. I think this story is one of the BEST things you've written! It's has so much heartfelt anguish and stunning joy! The characters are almost perfect in tone and voice. My only complaint is that the ending was little rushed, but that is a small thing in the scope of things. Bravo! Just bravo.
Author's Response: Thank you so much for the lovely review! I'm glad you tried it.
Oh my gosh, I just-
I can't express in words how beautiful this is. It's been a while since a fic has made me cry.
Thank you for this.
Author's Response: Thank you so much for your kind words! I'm glad you liked it.
I know you aren't around much anymore and I don't know that I have ever reviewed this, but I just wanted to take a moment and tell you this is one of my favorites, it has the right amount of sorrow but with a happy ending at the end.
Author's Response: I'm around, I'm just very quiet. ;) Thank you!
I can't do more than agree. A little too sumary in ending, I feel, but honest and deeply heartshaking. And yes, I cried too.
It made my heart ache and my stomach clench. It made me cry. I can't put any more than that into words, except to say that your skill shone with the different voices and made me wish to experience what Storm saw between them, even if only a pale shadow. Beautiful.
Humbly and respectfully yours,
Melanie
Author's Response: I'm the one humbled by such generous praise. I'm very happy to hear that you enjoyed my story--you readers are what make it all worth the work. Thank you so much.
Epic drama, dark and wonderful, and I enjoyed it immensely. Brava. Cuthalion
Speechless -not something that happens to me very often!
This fic was absolutely wonderful – It is by far the most heartbreaking and moving I’ve read.
Author's Response: I am going to have to argue with you about being speechless. *g* Thank you for all the wonderful feedback and for working your way through the catalogue! I'm very flattered (and impressed by your dedication!).